August, 22nd 2007

Metro Restaurant

On invitation by the
Swiss General Council
Walter Deplazes

Roundtable Luncheon on Direct Democracy
in Vancouver (CAN)


Some hypothesis for a fruitful discussion by Andreas Gross (Zurich/St-Ursanne)

1. Direct Democracy (DD) is not a Swiss invention – Switzerland just used best the French ideas from 1793 during the 19.century.

2. 1848, when modern Switzerland was founded, it was a European pioneer in universal men’s suffrage and parliamentary representation. Essentially the Swiss liberal founders created a parliamentary democracy.

3. It was the experiences of the weaknesses of the parliamentary democracy which motivated broad people’s movements after 1860 to ask for more participative rights; after early successes in different cantons, the Referendum was adopted federally 1874 and the Initiative 1891.

4. It’s very interesting that 30-40 years later similar people out of similar experiences and with similar hopes and ideas asked for the same constitutional changes in California and Oregon while referring explicitly to the earlier Swiss experiences. (J.W. Sullivan from NY/ K. Bürkli from ZH)

5. A similar, less successful “export” happened to Australia, and the Progressives in the Canadian Prairies took up DD in their manifesto of the 1920’s – most probably after the successful progressive campaigns in Oregon and California and interestingly enough in a total different institutional environment (British Commonwealth and Westminster System).

6. After this short show up DD seems to have been lost in the Canadian Democracy Reform Discourse. Why?

7. The term Referendum has in Canada a kind of authority driven connotation. The Canadian people do not control the process; the Government and the Parliament do. Essential and modern in Direct Democracy is the fact, that at any time a minority of citizens may bring any subject from the Parliament to the vote of all the people or as a proposal, to revise the constitution, to the evaluation of all the citizens.

8. This power of active citizens changes quite fundamentally the political power structures and the political cultures: Institutions and politicians have to listen much more carefully to citizens, they have to be better informed, they discuss political issues in a less personalized and much more substance orientated sense. Politics become softer, more communicative, nobody can command, everybody has to try to convince.

9. Individually citizens in a DD are therefore better informed, have a greater political knowledge, do feel less alienated and have more access to politicians, politics, institutions and polity.

10. DD should never be opposed to indirect Democracy; the latter is an integral part of the former. Even more so: DD makes representative Democracy more representative.

11. The power in a DD is more equally distributed. No one has so much power, that he or she might avoid learning. The whole society has a bigger learning capacity, because any group or organization has the opportunity to propose learning ways they think are in the interest of the society.

12. This is modern because citizens, more and more used to a complex reality, can today seldom identify with a party; direct democracy allows them better to choose a party in the election and adjust in the vote on issues, where their position differs from the one of the chosen party.

13. DD is like a mirror of the society; the mirror is not responsible for the face you see every morning. In California DD has other effects and products than in Switzerland. However the DD-polity is very different too. In Switzerland the DD is more cooperative and process oriented, in California more antagonistic and speedy. Both polities could learn from each other to improve their different DD polities.

14. The Swiss DD has specific weaknesses (no public funding for parties or engaged citizen groups, weak citizen education infrastructure, not spending limits or transparency rules before votes, no constitutional court for the federal legislation etc.), which other countries would avoid while introducing DD.

15. Democracy is an ongoing never ending process about sharing power and consulting and integrating citizens in decision-making processes they are concerned. DD is a little bit less unfinished than Parliamentary Democracy only.

16. DD contributes essentially to the integration of the very fragmented, decentralized and highly varied Swiss society. This integrative function might be even more important in a very much bigger country like Canada, which is decentralized, and varied as well.


Kontakt mit Andreas Gross



Nach oben

Zurück zur Artikelübersicht